Insights

Nod vs the closed personal AI agents: Claude Duet, dots, Muse, Grok Bot and Tasks in Gemini

As of 18 November 2026. All six products are new — several are previews or waitlists — and they change week to week. Every fact comes from the vendors' own pages, checked on that date and listed at the end; "Not stated" means we could not find it there.

This year, five of the largest AI companies launched a personal agent: software that keeps working in the background, uses a browser of its own and asks before it acts. All five are closed — the vendor runs the agent, supplies or picks the model and holds the data. Nod, released by n8n Labs on 10 November, is open source and runs on your own machine. This is not a contest with a winner. They make different trade-offs, and for a European business some of them are not on offer at all.

Why these agents appeared in 2026

Three things came together. Models became good enough to use a browser and finish a multi-step job rather than describe it. Vendors built secure cloud machines to run them on: each of the five gives its agent a virtual computer, so it keeps working when your laptop is closed. And the approval problem found a design answer — separate checks, protected credentials and one-time virtual cards that let an agent act without seeing your password or card number.

The closed agents in brief

Claude Duet (Anthropic)

Announced on 21 October 2026 as a research preview by waitlist, starting with US Pro, Max and Ultra subscribers; it is included in those plans and shares their usage limits. Anthropic designed it around Claude Opus 5.5, for professionals and small business owners. It runs in a virtual machine with its own browser, reaches more than 6,000 connectors and plugins in the Claude Marketplace, and checks your connected accounts every few hours. Before it sends a message, makes a payment, signs a document or deletes anything, it shows you exactly what it will do and waits; trading securities and moving money between accounts are off-limits even with approval. Anthropic says it may still misread a thread or misjudge urgency, and that personal errands are weaker than work tasks.

dots (OpenAI)

Introduced on 29 September 2026 at DevDay. A dot works on its own cloud computer; access to your local computer is optional and off by default. It reaches more than 4,000 apps through OpenAI's plugin ecosystem, and you set rules for what runs automatically and what needs approval. It launched on GPT-6 Astra; a 3 November update added GPT-6.1 Terra, and a dot can use different OpenAI models for different parts of its work. The first dot is included in Pro or Business Premium at no extra cost — but the Pro rollout excludes the EEA, Switzerland and the UK, and Business Premium depends on region and workspace eligibility.

Muse (Meta)

Announced on 8 September 2026 and powered by Muse Spark, Meta's own model. Muse lives on Muse Secure VM, a dedicated cloud machine that holds the agent and the person's data; a separate Sentinel agent on the same machine must approve anything that reaches the internet. You message it in the Muse app or in WhatsApp. Meta says Muse does not share conversations or VM data with its ad systems, offers a training opt-out and cannot see passwords or payment methods. It is free for most use, with subscriptions for more, and rolling out in the US. A Muse Confidential VM, encrypted with a key only the user holds, is announced for later.

Grok Bot (SpaceX Super Intelligence)

Grok Bot 1.0, from SpaceX Super Intelligence (SpaceXSI), launched on 11 November 2026 after a beta. Your Bots share one persistent cloud computer, and a Bot runs commands on your own desktop only if you allow it — by default it asks each time. There is no model picker: each task may run on a SpaceXSI model or a third-party model from its sub-processor list, and Grok Bot does not show which. It is included in The X Subscription's Premium, Super and Ultra plans, as well as some legacy Cursor plans, and it signs in with a Cursor account. Apps exist for macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS and Android.

Tasks in Gemini (Google)

Google tested it in beta as Gemini Spark from May, then renamed it. You switch the Gemini composer from Chat to Task and choose the Gemini model and thinking level. It can work in a remote browser or your local Chrome, runs code on a remote computer, and connects to Google apps — Gmail, Calendar, Drive, Docs, Sheets, Slides, YouTube, Maps — plus more than 50 third-party apps, all off by default. It always asks before sending messages, deleting data, buying or submitting forms. It needs a personal Google Account (not a work or school one) and users aged 18 or over. It is free in the US, Canada, Australia, India, Japan and South Korea, requires Google AI Pro or Ultra elsewhere, and is not available in the EEA, Nigeria, Switzerland or the UK.

And Nod, for reference

Open source under Apache-2.0 and free; it runs on your Mac, on Windows or Linux in preview, or on your own server, with any of 30-plus model providers or a local model. It has been a research preview since 10 November 2026.

Side by side

Basics: source, model, where it runs, status
CriterionNodClaude DuetdotsMuseGrok BotTasks in Gemini
Licence and sourceOpen source, Apache-2.0ClosedClosedClosedClosedClosed
Who picks the modelYou: 30+ providers or a local modelVendor: designed around Claude Opus 5.5Vendor: OpenAI models (GPT-6 Astra, GPT-6.1 Terra)Vendor: Muse SparkVendor, per task; the model used is not shownYou, among Gemini models and thinking levels
Where the agent runsYour computer or your own serverAnthropic's virtual machine with its own browserOpenAI's cloud computer; access to your computer optional, off by defaultMeta's cloud VM (Muse Secure VM)A persistent cloud computer; commands on your desktop only if you allow itA remote browser and computer, or your local Chrome
StatusResearch preview since 10 Nov 2026Research preview by waitlist since 21 Oct 2026Introduced 29 Sep 2026Announced 8 Sep 2026; rolling outVersion 1.0 since 11 Nov 2026Renamed from Gemini Spark (beta since May 2026); Google calls it experimental
Data and Europe: availability, memory, credentials, training and telemetry
CriterionNodClaude DuetdotsMuseGrok BotTasks in Gemini
Availability in the EU and SwitzerlandWherever you install it; your model provider's terms applyStarting with US subscribersPro rollout excludes the EEA, Switzerland and the UKRolling out in the USNot statedNot available in the EEA or Switzerland
Where memory and credentials liveOn the machine running Nod; secrets in the Vault, never seen by the modelAnthropic's VM; never directly sees passwords or sign-in tokensNot statedOn the Muse VM; credentials in secure storage the agent cannot seeOn the cloud computer; sign-ins without the agent seeing the valuesYour Google Account; remote browser data can be deleted
Training useSet by your model providerNot statedNot statedOpt-out availableFollows your Cursor account settingsNot stated
Telemetry defaultsUsage analytics on by default; conversation traces offNot statedNot statedNot statedNot statedNot stated
Control and cost: approvals, integrations, pricing, fit
CriterionNodClaude DuetdotsMuseGrok BotTasks in Gemini
Approval and safety modelSeparate check before it sends, pays, posts or deletes; asks when instructions don't cover an action; actions loggedApproval before sending, paying, signing or deleting; trading securities and moving money off-limitsYour rules decide what runs automatically and what needs approvalA separate Sentinel agent gates internet access; asks before sensitive actions; full audit trailDepends on the tool, the risk and your Auto-review rulesAlways asks before sending, deleting, purchases, payments and form submissions
Integrations and channelsGmail, Calendar, Drive, Slack, websites, MCP, APIs; app, Telegram, WhatsApp6,000+ connectors and plugins; iOS, Android, claude.ai4,000+ apps via OpenAI pluginsMuse app and WhatsAppConnectors and websites; desktop and mobile apps, X Chat, SlackGoogle apps and 50+ third-party apps, all off by default
Pricing modelFree; you pay your model providerIncluded in Pro, Max and Ultra; shares usage limitsFirst dot included in Pro or Business PremiumFree for most use; subscriptions for moreIncluded in The X Subscription Premium ($30/month), Super ($100), Ultra ($200)Free in six countries; Google AI Pro or Ultra elsewhere
Who it suitsHands-on owners comfortable managing API keysUS Claude subscribers who want a work-focused agentChatGPT Pro or Business Premium users in supported regionsUS users who want an agent inside WhatsAppX Subscription and Cursor users, and teamsPeople with a personal Google Account outside Europe

What lock-in means here

  • Vendor. With a closed agent, your routines, its memory and its connections live in the vendor's account; leaving means rebuilding them elsewhere. Nod keeps them on your machine, and its code is Apache-2.0 — but it is a Labs experiment, so "open source" also means someone has to maintain it if n8n moves on.
  • Model. Claude Duet, dots and Muse run on their vendor's models; Grok Bot routes between models it does not disclose; Tasks in Gemini lets you pick, among Gemini models. Nod treats the model as a setting: a US frontier model, Mistral, or a model on your own hardware.
  • Where data lives. The closed agents keep the agent, its memory and the credentials it uses on the vendor's cloud — that is what lets them work while you sleep. Nod keeps all of that on your machine, yet the model provider still receives what each task needs.
  • Availability in Europe. Today, dots on Pro and Tasks in Gemini explicitly exclude the EEA and Switzerland; Claude Duet and Muse are starting in the US; Grok Bot's documentation states no regional policy. For a business in Lisbon, Lyon or Lugano, that is the first filter, before any feature comparison.

When a closed agent is the better choice

Fairly often. If it is available where you are, a closed agent asks almost nothing of you: no machine to keep awake, no API keys, usually a plan you already pay for instead of per-token bills, and a mobile app that simply works. The connector catalogues are far larger — thousands of apps for Claude Duet and dots. If your team already lives in one vendor's plan, its agent inherits that context; Claude Duet, for example, carries over your memory, skills and connected apps from Claude. Muse needs nothing more than WhatsApp. And the vendors' safety layers — Sentinel, approval rules, off-limits actions, virtual cards — are designed and staffed by large teams.

Practical guidance for European SMBs

  1. Check availability first, for your country and your account type: some agents need a personal account rather than a work one.
  2. Decide what may leave the building. An agent reads email, calendars and invoices; write down what is off-limits before you connect anything.
  3. Choose the model before the agent. With Nod, that choice decides where task data goes — an EU region, Mistral, or a local model.
  4. Start with reading and drafting. Keep approvals on for anything that sends, pays or deletes.
  5. Set a spending ceiling. Per-task costs surprised even Nod's early testers.
  6. Look again in three months. These products are changing every week.

Sources (checked 18 November 2026)

Frequently asked questions

Which of these agents can a business in Portugal, France, Spain or Italy use today?
As of 18 November 2026, dots (on the Pro plan) and Tasks in Gemini explicitly exclude the EEA and Switzerland, Claude Duet and Muse are starting in the US, and Grok Bot's documentation states no regional policy. Nod runs wherever you install it, subject to your model provider's terms.
Is an open-source agent automatically more private?
No. Nod keeps its database, memory and saved logins on your own machine, but the model provider you connect still receives what each task needs, and Nod's usage analytics are on by default. Privacy depends on the model you choose and the settings you keep.
Can I choose the AI model in the closed agents?
Mostly not. Claude Duet, dots and Muse run on their vendor's own models, and Grok Bot picks a model per task without showing which. Tasks in Gemini lets you choose among Gemini models only. Nod lets you choose among 30-plus providers or a local model.
Why do the closed agents run in the vendor's cloud?
So they can keep working when your laptop is closed. Each gives its agent its own virtual computer and browser. The trade-off is that the agent, its memory and the credentials it uses live on the vendor's infrastructure.
Which one is best?
There is no single answer. A closed agent suits you if it is available in your country, you already pay for that vendor's plan and you want nothing to maintain. Nod suits you if you want control over the model and where the agent runs, and accept a research preview.
← All insights

Let’s solve it.

Tell us about your business and what you’d like solved. We reply personally within one business day.

Start a project